Powered by Top Rated Local®

Saddle Fitting

One of the most intuitive fitting processes out there! We utilize pictures and video in motion to insure a great, functional fit for your horse. Once that is complete, we customize to you!

Get Started

Custom Saddles

Custom design your own work of art from our many models and options, or scroll down for "in-stock" models that are ready to go!

View All Custom Saddles

Tack Shop

Easy online shopping for all your tack and accessory needs! We offer a wide variety of saddle accessories for you and your horse.

View Tack Shop

Allegany Mountain Saddlery

Handmade, custom-fit Western trail saddles and more

Allegany Mountain Saddlery (AMS) is a trail rider’s best source for custom Western horse saddles. Each of our customized western saddles is carefully fitted to you and your horse with your individual purpose in mind.

We focus on crafting comfortable, lightweight trail saddles which stand up to years of use in the toughest conditions. Our professionally designed Western saddles are hand crafted to provide a lifetime of riding pleasure with optimum comfort. Being comfortable while knowing your horse is comfortable makes your trail riding experience so much more enjoyable.

Custom Western Saddle Fittings

A custom saddle represents a considerable investment and we at AMS understand this very important decision.

Achieving the proper fit between saddle, horse and rider is essential for overall trail riding comfort. Because of our focus on quality and riding comfort, we primarily use saddle trees created by Steele Saddle Tree, LLC in all our custom-made saddles. Steele has been building saddle trees for over 150 years and is the recognized leader and authority in this industry. Their saddle trees provide AMS with numerous fitting options and the flexibility to create an unlimited range of styles and fits that conform to the size and shape of your horse as well as your riding discipline.

Every saddle is individually hand crafted right here in the USA. Top quality leather is hand-picked from Wicket & Craig™ and our hardware is of only the highest quality brass and stainless steel. Our experienced saddlers integrate quality workmanship throughout the process from selection of leather and hardware to cutting and sewing to assembling your finished saddle.

Each of our custom saddles is designed around you and your horse. AMS's saddle fitting kits simplify this process as much as possible fitting even the hardest-to-fit horses to create a tree that properly fits your horse. Allegany Mountain Saddlery has one of the most in-depth saddle fitting procedures available for remote fitting. We will personally work with you during each step in the construction process to ensure the best possible fit for your horse resulting in a saddle you will enjoy!

And, for your peace of mind, we offer a 100 percent satisfaction money back guarantee!

Additional Saddle Fitting Options

We can build on a tree by any maker you wish if you would like to provide your own.  Call us to explore your options.

We also offer in person fittings at our facility or your stable. Our fully equipped mobile unit is available for servicing groups.  Contact us on (716) 257 9574 to schedule a fitting clinic for your group or organization.

If you are not interested in a custom fitting, we also offer some straight run saddles in stock, both new and lightly used. Select from a variety of custom Wade saddles, endurance saddles, Amish saddles and many other western trail riding saddles. We carry Quarter horse bar saddles, gaited saddles, draft saddles, mule saddles, custom tack to match your saddle and much, much more in our online tack shop!

The Custom Shop
All seats are built custom! You will be asked about what "rise" you prefer, and what width "twist." No worries, we'll chat about it and figure out what is best for you!
Custom Order Now Saddle Fitting Saddle Options - Tack
In-Stock & Used Saddles View All
SW western

Used SW Bar Western Trail

X bar kydaho

Lightly Used X bar Kydaho

NE cascade wade

Used NE Cascade Wade

J bar kydaho

Used J bar Kydaho

D bar renegade

New D Bar Renegade Endurance

wade

New DF Bar Wade

Used Western trail saddle

Used PW Western Trail

Westen trail saddle

New CM Western Trail

PW cascade wad

New PW Cascade Wade

XB saddle

New XB Western Trail

LT endurance saddle

New LT Renegade Endurance

Aw wade saddle

New AW Bar Cascade Wade 17.5

Trail saddle

Lightly Used PW Bar Western Trail

HW bar saddle

New Renegade Endurance HW bar

Custom X bar

Used Custom X bar

AW bar endurance saddle

Lightly Used AW Bar Renegade

D bar renegade

Renegade Endurance Gently Used Quarter Horse (D+1/4) Fit

XF bar

New Renegade Endurance XF Bar

Wide AW

Lightly Used Western Trail (AW)

DF bar western trail

New Cascade Wade (DF)

DF bar western trail

Lightly Used DF Bar Western trail

Frequently Asked Questions about Custom Western Trail Riding Saddles